| Year | Rector | Patron | Remarks | 
  
    | 1229 | Henry de Gray | Prior & Convent of Repton |  | 
  
    | 1240 | John le Vavasour | Prior & Convent of Repton |  | 
  
    | 1245 | Walter le Vavasour | Prior & Convent of Repton |  | 
  
    | 1251 | Henry le Vavasour | Prior & Convent of Repton | died 1280 | 
  
    | 1281 | Roger le Hengham | Prior & Convent of Repton |  | 
  
    | 1298 | Henry le Sutton | Prior & Convent of Repton |  | 
  
    | 1308 | Reymond Wm de Fergis | Prior & Convent of Repton |  | 
  
    | 1347 | Robert de Clypston | King Edward III | Repton Priory being vacant | 
  
    | 1364 | Thomas de Bildeston | Prior & Convent of Repton |  | 
  
    | 1404 | John de Barford | Prior & Convent of Repton |  | 
  
    | 1441 | John Torald | Prior & Convent of Repton | became Rector of Rempstone | 
  
    | 1455 | Richard Mysin | Prior & Convent of Repton | Bishop of York 1460 | 
  
    | 1462 | Roger Smyth | Prior & Convent of Repton | died 1472,buried in church | 
  
    | 1473 | William Fitzherbert | John & Richard Fitzherbert | resigned | 
  
    | 1476 | Nicholas Fitzherbert | Prior & Convent of Repton | resigned | 
  
    | 1517 | Julian Crosby | Prior & Convent of Repton | last presentee of Repton | 
  
    | 1554 | Richard Walker | Air John Porte |  | 
  
    | 1567 | Matthew Hutton STP | Archbishop of York | Bishop of Durham 1589 | 
  
    | 1568 | Thomas Baldwyn | Sir George Hastings Knight | through his wife Dorothy Porte | 
  
    | 1598 | Churstan Chapleyn | Sir George Hastings Knight |  | 
  
    | 1612 | John Davenant | Henry Earl of Huntingdon | Bishop of Salisbury 1621 | 
  
    | 1620 | Edward Bigland | Henry Earl of Huntingdon | buried West Leake Aug 9 1650 | 
  
    | 1662 | John Moorre | Gervas Pigott Esq | buried West Leake Aug 28 1667 | 
  
    | 1667 | John Davys | Lucy Countess of Huntingdon | buried West Leake Oct 13 1717 | 
  
    | 1717 | Michael Stanhope STP | Frances Stanhope | gt-gr-son of 1st Earl of Chesterfield | 
  
    | 1737 | Granville Wheler | Theophilus Earl of Huntingdon |  | 
  
    | 1772 | Robert Hemington |  | buried West Leake Jan 7 1775 | 
  
    | 1772 | Edward Ellis |  |  | 
  
    | 1795 | Theophilus Henry Hastings MA | Francis Rawdon Hastings Earl of Moira
 | hostility to local non-conformists buried West Leake April 9th 1803
 | 
  
    | 1804 | George Holcombe DD & JP | Francis Rawdon Hastings | buried West Leake Feb 13 1836 | 
  
    | 1836 | John Bateman MA | John Bateman | last Joint Rector of E & W. Leake buried West Leake May 6 1882
 | 
  
    | 1882 | Henry Balfour Hamilton | Lord Belper |  | 
  
    | 1909 | Richard Owen Jones | Lord Belper | buried at West Leake July 31 1945 | 
  
    | 1932 | Charles Herbert Vincent Brown | Lord Belper | Joined Benefice of West Leake | 
  
    | 1932 | Norman Wrigley | Lord Belper | Ratcliffe on Soar & Kingston on Soar | 
  
    | 1938 | Philip New | Lord Belper |  | 
  
    | 1946 | John Frederick Theodor Martin | Lord Belper |  | 
  
    | 1951 | Cyril Brailsford | Lord Belper |  | 
  
    | 1955 | Ieuan Williams | Lord Belper |  | 
  
    | 1962 | John William Mayer | Lord Belper |  | 
  
    | 1968 | Norman Copeland | Lord Belper | Priest in charge, Rector of Gotham | 
  
    | 1982 | David James | Lord Belper | Joined East Leake Benefice | 
  
    | 1984 | Stephen John Smith | Lord Belper |  | 
  
    | 2000 | Glynis Hetherington | Lord Belper |  |