| Annesley Old ChurchList of IncumbentsThe following is a list of all the incumbents up to the transfer of the
    living to the New Church in 1874. The later
    incumbents are listed separately. The old Saxon Church
  
    | C1100 | St Robert of Felley, Hermit |  The old Norman Church, built c1150
  
    | 1156 | Prior Walter |  
    | C1170 | Prior Adam of Nocton |  
    | C1180 | Prior William of Lovetot |  
    | C1200 | Prior Richard of Thurgaton |  
    | C1220 | Prior Henry |  
    |  | Prior Thomas |  
    | C1240 | Prior Walter |  
    | C1250 | Prior Henry |  
    | 1268 | Prior Ralph of Pleasley |  
    | 1276 | Prior Thomas of Wathenowe |  
    | 1281 | Prior Alam of Elkesley |  
    | C1300 | Prior William of Toton |  
    | 1315 | Prior Elias of Linby |  
    | C1322 | Prior Adam |  
    | 1328 | Prior John of Kirkby |  
    | 1349 | Prior John of Holbrook |  
    | 1349 | Prior Richard of Shirebrook |  The old Annesley Church, built 1356
  
    | C1360 | Prior Robert Eaves |  
    | 1378 | Prior Thomas Elmton |  
    | 1381 | Prior John of Mansfield |  
    | C1390 | Prior William of Tuxford |  
    | 1405 | Prior William Hopwood |  
    | 1442 | Prior Peter Methley |  
    | C1450 | Prior John Throughcroft |  
    | 1454 | Prior William Acwarth |  
    | 1463 | Prior Richard Congreve |  
    | 1482 | Prior William Symondson (alias Bolton) |  
    | 1500 | Prior Lawrence Ingham |  
    | C1510 | Prior Robert (or Thomas) Gateford |  
    | 1519 | Prior Thomas Stock |  
    | 1525 | Prior Christopher Bolton |  Up to 1536, all Vicars of Annesley were also the Priors of Felley. The Priory
  at Felley was dissolved in 1536 and Christopher Bolton accepted the living
  of Attenborough. 
  
    | 1536 | Richard Samond |  
    | 1573 | George Holme |  
    | 1576 | William Bradford |  
    | 1587 | Nicholas Bee |  
    | 1599 | Thomas Kirkby |  
    | 1604 | Joseph Holte |  
    | 1609 | Thomas Reste |  
    | 1617 | Anthony Robinson |  
    | 1621 | Robert Aynsworth |  
    | 1622-29 | William Perry |  
    | 1630-38 | William Hewitt |  
    | 1639-42 | Thomas Bowes |  
    | 1651-55 | Cuthbert Stote |  
    | 1656 | Christopher Sanderson |  
    | 1663-65 | Sampson Hopkyn |  
    | 1667-74 | Richard Munn |  
    | 1675-79 | Nicholas Sore |  
    | 1680-81 | George Sissons |  
    | 1682-84 | Thomas Howitt (see below) |  
    | 1684-85 | Thomas Knight |  
    | 1685-88 | Christopher Newton |  
    | 1688 | Thomas Kimpson |  
    | 1689-90 | Edward Hawkins |  
    | 1691-93 | Thomas Howitt (see above) |  
    | 1694-99 | Richard Kay |  
    | 1700-08 | Christopher Overend |  
    | 1709 | William Mince |  
    | 1710-62 | Andrew Matthews (also Rector of Linby, 1723-62) |  
    | 1762-94 | Robert Stanley (also Rector of Linby, 1762-94) |  
    | 1794-1805 | Thomas Cursham (also Schoolmaster of Sutton-in-Ashfield) |  
    | 1805-08 | William Clarke (also Vicar of Gonaldston, 1785-1808) |  
    | 1809 | William Tiffin |  
    | 1811-48 | John Rolleston (also Vicar of Burton
        Joyce, 1822-62) |  
    | 1814-18 | Guy Bryan (Curate) |  
    | 1819-21 | Henry Jenour (Curate) (Rector of Epperstone 1822-29) |  
    | 1822-47 | Thomas Leeson Cursham (Curate) |  
    | 1848 | Richard Howard Frizell |  
    | 1869 | James John Trebeck |  
    | 1869-70 | Francis Douglas Dymock (Curate) |  
    | 1871 | Clement Howard Prance |  The New Church was consecrated in 1874,
  and from that date onwards the Vicars of
  Annesley have been based there. |